
Fear the IRS! Armed IRS Criminal Investigators really can seize you SWAT style, but Alcatraz was meant for modern Al Capones. It is far more likely that the IRS will write you first with obtuse style, then make demands that presume you had higher income or lower expenses as you helplessly seek palliatives. You might also appoint your champion—a lawyer, CPA or Enrolled Agent—to state your case informed by the law and with the ability to say “I don’t know” to delay proceedings or collections to your advantage.
The IRS website defines an audit as “…a review/examination of an organization’s or individual’s books, accounts and financial records to ensure information is reported per tax law. …” Audits hit returns based on statistical norms or challenges with related parties (e.g. business partners) and auditors will ask for documents related to income or deductions (e.g. receipts, payroll records, 1099s). Most audits go back just three years, but my record was 23 years for an unfiled drug dealer return. What if the brokerage reports gains that your investment partnership forgot to state or the taxpayer gifts to unauthorized charities. Congress developed interlocking systems of income reporting that make cheating difficult—even if the IRS doesn’t look into bank and credit accounts.
This Enrolled Agent has represented a doctor, a lawyer and a tech entrepreneur; all are vulnerable. Correspondence audits, less disruptive, usually request specific records. The taxpayer and/or their representative meet at an IRS office, a tax office or the client’s workplace (so the IRS can gather random information) and I met at a yoga studio and an electronics dealership. Taxpayers stand less than a 1% chance of audit but million-dollar earners leap to 2.7%. EITC claimants see higher audit rates because cost-effective correspondence audits bring revenues faster than business audits.
Questioning Records
The IRS challenged a techie who claimed $900,000 charity. The IRS agent walked out of our office empty-handed because we showed receipts for every penny and $4 million income. A realtor followed me into IRS San Jose without receipts to prove 100 grand of expenses and the IRS agent simply crossed off every unauthenticated claim he made. The realtor fared worst on mileage without good logbooks. Yes, auditors subpoena banks for your records!
Payroll Audits
A lawyer faced a payroll audit because the FTB believed he hired other lawyers and paralegals as contractors when they truly were employees. This is a common audit because employers would love to avoid IRS payroll taxes (12.4% SSA and 2.9% Medicare), 3.4% Unemployment Insurance for new employers on the first $7,000 income and 1.3% California State Disability Insurance policies.
The Quest for Justice
One client did 20 years of backdoor Roth conversions and, over three years of appeals, we finally proved his Roth basis. In a fight over realty basis, I appealed to the doors of Tax Court where lawyers squabble; but the IRS attorney proved the client had exaggerated. Mediation, rapid appeals and the independent Taxpayer Advocate service can resolve problems through law. Petition the Tax Court within 90 days of notices of deficiency.
Criminal Activity?
A total of 2,200 Special Investigations agents, focusing on intentional tax fraud, narcotics and money laundering, convicted just 1,571 people in 2024 but discovered $9.1 billion defrauded in 2024. Faked records, faulty FBARs or bank deposits far above reported income cause civil cases to become criminal with proof of willful fraud. Whistleblowing spouses, business partners or other agencies refer cases, or AI-tools flag unwarranted lifestyles. Prosecutions are expensive but sometimes a single exemplary criminal can help the IRS destroy an illegal tax loophole? The IRS convicted actor Weslie Snipes, who claimed income was not taxable; then fined him $5 million and made him serve three years in jail.
My “IRS Collections” article explains payments after resistance fails. Tax authorities scare most people enough to keep them mostly honest about tax reporting. Representatives squabble before supposedly neutral Tax Courts to apply or set legal precedents. Loyal citizens respond with voluntary compliance to the ultimate threat of force: this is an amazing feat for a country founded in tax revolt and tea tossing.
Robert Arne, EA, CFP, MS, of Carpe Diem Financial Life Planning, gives holistic financial and tax advice as his client’s fee-only fiduciary. This Mortgage Loan Originator (NMLS #2565162) serves mostly Santa Cruz Mountain dwellers. These articles must not be read as personal financial, mortgage, tax or investment advice; consult appropriate professionals. Learn more at www.carpediem.financial.










